Erald, July 12, 2016
We’ve researched the costs hiring Mobile Point of Sale Card Terminals and the several large card payment providers and in UK and found some shocking information about their pricing and the hidden fees for using their services. We will explore the truth about the pricing when it comes to accepting debit/ credit cards as a business including at shows or exhibitions.
The Oxford Economics study by Facetime.org of 2010 throws light into the total spend at UK exhibitions to be around £2.6 billion in value added (GDP) for the UK economy in 2010. Combine that with the fact that the amount of money being spent on cards in the UK is a whopping £600 billion and you see that taking cards at exhibitions is vital to growing your business and sales (Source: UKCardsAssociation.org).
So you may have a Credit Card Reader already or are thinking about hiring one. After doing some research we found the average was £103 for three days credit card reader hire and a rubbishy rate (we called four places associated with big exhibition venues). We were stunned.
So then we looked at the big boys in the market for card readers and the results were shocking …
A study done by the UK card association stated that:
“Overall, three in every four pounds (75 per cent) spent at UK retailers were on a debit or credit card last year, up 10 percentage points since 2009. People use debit cards more than credit cards for spending, with 77 per cent of all card purchases in the UK made using a debit card. Just over 1.1 million outlets now accept cards, an increase of 4.2 per cent on 2013, as a growing number of small traders now take them.”
(Source: UK Card Association)
Many have turned to the larger companies like Worldpay or Paypal for these facilities. Banks like Lloyds or Barclays offer merchant accounts which are incredibly expensive and often require a large deposit to be put down to cover charge backs, something not all small businesses can provide.
Unfortunately, not all these options are as cost effective as they might seem at first glance. We have looked at some of the largest Card Payment Providers in the UK and analysed their costs for taking card payments face-to-face, over the telephone and through emailed paylinks. We have then compared it to SmartTrade App to show you why we are the best option for small businesses when it comes to taking card payments.
For the sake of accuracy and non-bias I have included screenshots from the companies actual websites to back up the information provided in this article.
Online: Online customer Cards 3.5% + 20p for online (via the web this is £35.20 cost per £1,000!) and get 1.9% at £15,000 per month turnover (a poor rate for such high turnover).
Face to Face: PayPal Reader £79.95 customer cards 2.75% up to £6,000 per month, £6k – £10k = 2.4% + 20p
* 3.40% + 20p for card payments made by swiping the magnetic strip or manually entering the card details.
Over the telephone: Take customer cards over the telephone £20pm and same card rates as online. Online Cards 3.5% + 20p for online (via the web) and get 1.9% at £15,000 per month.
Outside EU Cards 3.9% per transaction on top
Summary: I was amazed by how expensive Paypal really was. As a small business if you are turning over £6,000 a month (which is a lot) you would have to give up 2.75% of each penny and pound up to this amount. That’s £165 a month or almost £2,000 a year until you go over £6,000, where it becomes 2.4% + 20p. Hardly a massive drop for that sort of turnover. Also, with across border fees you could end up paying over 7% percent for an international transaction. That’s £70 per £1,000 transaction. Crazy! The card reader is also very expensive at £79.95. The card rates are a nasty shock as you have to dig quite deep to find out what you actually pay with Paypal.
2.95% for card payments over the phone
Amex’s charged at 2.75% and so are all monthly transactions up to £2,500
Rates range from 2.75% – 1.5% depending on volume.
That’s coupled with very expensive card readers might price out many small – medium businesses.
Summary: Initially Payleven looked good. Their card rates are decent and are low for high volumes. But, they charge 2.95% for over the phone transactions and 2.75% for Amex’s. For companies who do a lot of transactions through a virtual terminal this is bad news as they won’t benefit from the low rates unless transactions are done through their card readers, which isn’t always possible. The card readers are another problem, alongside a receipt printer they could run you over £200. No emailed receipts? Also no paylinks so you don’t really get a full package and limits the way you can take card payments.
Face to Face: You need to rent a card machine for a certain amount of months, usually 36 months but you could haggle them down to 18 months if you are good at bartering – costs are over £20 a month just for this service. There is also a cancellation fee for backing out early.
You also have to pay for PCI compliance: “You will still need to pay the £29.99 annual management as this is applicable to all customers irrespective of your compliance status. – See more here” – Worldpay Website
£7.50 per month for virtual terminal
Paylinks £7.50 a month:
4 working days to clear
Total package can add up to a lot for face to face card payments, payments over the phone or emailed paylinks, not exactly the cheapest for small to medium sized businesses and the lock in contracts for the card readers is a killer.
Summary: Worldpay are the largest card payment provider in the UK with over 52% of the UK market. There is no denying they are great for retail stores or large chains who don’t pay much attention to “small” costs such as card fees. I also do not doubt the quality of their service, I just don’t think they are as good for small-medium businesses or large companies with a mobile work force. Pay as you go is a pretty standard 2.75% + 20p and their £19.95 Pay Monthly boasts the same fee of 2.75% for credit cards and an impressive 0.75% for debits. If we want to get a full package here is how it would look. At least an 18 month contract for a card reader at £20+ per month. £7.50 a month for card payments over the phone. £7.50 a month for paylinks. £29.99 annual PCI charge. The costs just keep stacking up and I don’t see this as a very viable option for many businesses.
iZettle do a decent deal for small-medium sized merchants who want to take card payments face to face.
Transparent pricing which changes depending on volume per month.
They do require a card reader and have two options, one is free but is limited. It does not take contactless transactions or have a display. The other card reader is £59 and requires a bluetooth connection which is sometimes unreliable.
They do not offer a virtual terminal for card payments over the phone.
And they do not offer customers the option to get paid by link.
Summary: Good if you really need to use a card reader and you don’t need any other service. For transactions up to £2,000 a month it still ends up being 2.75% per transaction. It’s not a complete payments package so you would need to take on other services to get over the phone payments, paylinks and accounting integration.
No card reader needed
Take payments on Mobile App and Web Dashboard
Paperless invoices, quotes and receipts
Online via emailed paylinks: 2.15% + 20p
Face to Face: 2.15% + 20p
Over the telephone: 2.15% + 20p
Maximum card fee is 2.15% + 20p for subscribed users, negotiable depending on volume
Plus Card Transaction fees that can be 0%. Yup 0% per card transaction! Card fees can be split or completely passed onto the customer bill. SmartTrade App is the only service that offers this feature.
All mentioned features are part of the Lone Ranger Package for £8.49pm.
Picture at top of article by Lucy Stash.at Lucy Stash’s blog